Which of the Doctor's companions do you think he could have done without? Which one would you send out to fight a squad of Daleks with a hose pipe?

What's your reason?

Kamelion

Say no more

Mel and Ace

Not often I disagree with you Thasc.

I thought Ace was a perfectly good companion and I believe that once the baggage of season 26 was out of the way Dorothy could have made an excellent companion should there have been a season 27.

As for MEL...Hmmmmm!!!! You either loved or hated Mel. Mel would have been fine had Colin stayed on, however a big mismatch with Sylv. A bit too excitable for my tastes

Possibly Susan. She was too much of a whinge-bag to be honest, which was a shame.

Mel and Tegan are the ones who immediately spring to mind. I'm surpised that this post has been open three days and no mention of Adric! Still, I wouldn't include him - I've never seen why he's so widely hated. :huh:

gotta hate someone! :lol: i think its because hes a wining adolescent, bratty child sort of image. i dont know, hes not that bad i dont think.

i'd have to say, Grace, kick her out and start afresh with Final Invasion (still available on the fan fic board! ;))

Mel... way too perky for my taste. I'd need at least three cups of coffee in me to keep me from pummeling her.

Her attire puts me off instantly :eek: :lol:

Still, Kate O'Mara's Mel in 'Time and the Rani' was an absolute hoot! :lol:

Grace.

I just didn't like the character at all.

Hi

Steven

As wooden as a door, as for Adric I think it is more Mathew then Adric


:thumbs:

Mel!!!!!!!!

At the time they were just looking for more nails in the shows coffin, and she fitted the bill perfectly :angry:

I always thought that Turlough was a whiny pain in the posterior as well, he was only remotely interesting when he was trying to kill the Doctor, then he got over that, and became a whiny assed Adric mark 2 :rolleyes: :lol:

I thought that Dodo was pretty annoying.... (Just thought I'd throw out a name that had not been mentioned yet.)