View Full Version: Doctor Who Dvd

Cult Tv Boards > Dr Who > Doctor Who Dvd



Title: Doctor Who Dvd
Description: pg-12?


prophecy girl - May 16, 2005 05:12 PM (GMT)
QUOTE

Rose (Billie Piper) encounters the captive Dalek in the episode
Young children will be unable to buy Doctor Who DVD of the latest TV series after censors objected to a scene showing a Dalek being tortured.
The DVD of episodes from the BBC show, starring Christopher Eccleston, has a 12 rating and unavailable to under-12s.

The British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) felt the Dalek episode showed "violence and cruelty as a way of dealing with problems".

Last month the BBC denied the series was too frightening for under-eights.

Captive taunted

In the episode - entitled Dalek and broadcast on BBC One last month - a collector chains up one of the killer creatures, which screams as its helmet is drilled into.

The Doctor, played Eccleston, is then seen to taunt the captured Dalek which is initially unable to retaliate.

He later attempts to shoot the Dalek at close range but is prevented from doing so by his companion Rose Tyler, played by Billie Piper.

  We are concerned about role models for children using the sort of tactics that Doctor Who used against the Dalek

British Board of Film Classification
"We are concerned about role models for children using the sort of tactics that Doctor Who used against the Dalek," a BBFC spokeswoman said.

"If that was transferred into the playground it would be something we would want to tackle."

The BBFC said 2004 movie Spider-Man 2 was similarly issued with a 12 certificate, rather than the less restrictive PG rating.

"It received a 12 because of its scenes of urban violence and the fact that role model Spider-Man used violence as a way of dealing with his problems."


The Doctor (Christopher Eccleston) is shown taunting the creature
Earlier episode The Unquiet Dead, which featured Victorian killer zombies, has also been released on DVD with a 12 certificate.

The BBC said it would not appeal against the BBFC rating.

"We would have preferred a PG rating but we were not willing to re-edit the episodes to obtain that - we wanted to release the episodes exactly as they had been on seen on TV," a spokeswoman said.

On its early evening broadcast in April, the BBC initially said The Unquiet Dead episode was not suitable for children under eight.

The corporation later revised its advice, stating that while the episode "may be scary", its content had been "carefully considered" for a pre-watershed audience.


Phillip Culley - May 16, 2005 05:15 PM (GMT)
I don't get it - for years us Doctor Who fans have been complaining that the show still gets treated as a kids show, yet the moment we get a higher BBFC rating we're complaining that it's too high... :)

Dan Brown - May 17, 2005 02:12 PM (GMT)
I'm not complaining one bit, I wouldn't mind if it got a 18 rating it was a good episode and this series has been catered more for adults as well, if it was just for kids then they could put it on CBBC.

Also parents have the last say in what children see on television and it doesn't really matter what rating Doctor Who gets when they are letting children play games like Grand Theft Auto which are ten times worse than any Doctor Who episode.

willowroolz - May 17, 2005 03:31 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Phillip Culley @ May 16 2005, 06:15 PM)
I don't get it - for years us Doctor Who fans have been complaining that the show still gets treated as a kids show, yet the moment we get a higher BBFC rating we're complaining that it's too high... :)

:lol: I've lost count of the number of times I've heard people say that they used to hide behind the couch when Doctor Who was on (myself included :fear: :lol: ), why should today's younger generation be spared that experience?

I read a few weeks back that the BBC had received 60 or so complaints about The Unquiet Dead. These complaints were no doubt from the same people who overlook the latest murder or miscellaneous other act of violence in their favourite soap so that they can lambast a w**k of the imagination instead.

Still, I suppose if any kids encounter a Dalek in their playground they'll be kind to it :rolleyes:




Hosted for free by InvisionFree